A soldier's sad story, one of a number

Published Monday November 10th, 2008
A1

SAINT JOHN - Matthew Charles Keddy used to be a happy young man who was excited about his life.

But according to his family that was before the 25-year-old Canadian Forces Base Gagetown soldier served in Afghanistan. He hasn't been the same since his return from the war-torn country.

He has suffered depression and anxiety, a suicide attempt, and in the summer he assaulted a woman who was then his girlfriend.

"Unfortunately, he was on the front lines in the infantry; he has seen things some of us will probably never see in our lives," his father told a court in Saint John recently, suggesting that his son is suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder.

As Keddy's behaviour was related to the court, the soldier sat in the prisoner's box, holding his head in his hands and rocking back and forth.

He has pleaded guilty to the July 13 assault in Oromocto, and is to be in court today to hear the results of his psychiatric assessment. He had been released on the assault charge pending sentencing after agreeing to not to have any contact with the woman.

But he has since pleaded guilty to violating the order.

In September, he tracked her down in Saint John after she moved away, called her multiple times at both her work and home, and showed up at her apartment door.

In October, Keddy, who had no prior criminal record, was before the court again for breaching an order not to be in Saint John for any reason other than gong to work. And he was picked up on Thanksgiving, threatening to jump off the Reversing Falls Bridge.

He spent five days in the psychiatric ward at the Saint John Regional Hospital and the following weekend at the Saint John Regional Correctional Centre.

"We've been dealing with this since he came back" from Afghanistan, his father told the court, his voice shaking as his wife fought back tears and reached for his hand. "It's one of the reasons we moved from Alberta" to Grand Bay-Westfield.

The couple has been seeking help for their youngest child, who has been out on stress leave and is taking anti-anxiety medication, and has been told there are "a number of people in the same situation."

Keddy's case follows comments by a senior military physician for the Atlantic provinces who said that more staff is needed at the mental health clinic at CFB Gagetown.

Cmdr. David Wilcox says an additional uniformed psychiatrist and more psychologists are needed to ensure the base continues to meet national wait time guidelines established by the Canadian Medical Association. Wilcox made the comments in June, while testifying before a House of Commons Standing Committee on National Defence about mental health services for soldiers in the Canadian Armed Forces.

Meanwhile, Fredericton psychologists Robin Geneau and Joyce Belliveau told the committee that services to treat soldiers at the base who are suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder are in disarray and carried out by unqualified mental health workers.

The standing committee has passed a motion recommending Auditor-General Sheila Fraser conduct a review of all Canadian Forces bases to evaluate services, treatment and care for mental health injuries.

On Oct. 20, duty counsel Margaret Gallagher requested the most recent charge against Keddy be adjourned without plea so a psychiatric assessment to determine whether he was criminally responsible could be conducted at the military base, where he lives.

"I just want to go home (with my parents)," Keddy said.

"If you send me up there (to the base), I'm going to go nuts.

"They say they're going to help me, but they don't help me.

"They don't care. They don't care."

After checking with military officials, Crown prosecutor Catherine McNally informed the court they weren't willing to conduct a psychiatric assessment. She also said they wouldn't "babysit" Keddy if the court planned to release him on house arrest at the barracks pending the assessment.

They would supervise him during his regular working hours of 7:30 a.m. to 4 p.m., and he could report to the duty centre every two hours up until midnight, but he'd be on his own after that.

"He's certainly not a 'baby' when they send him overseas in the middle of that," said a frustrated Judge William McCarroll.

"You'd think they'd ensure he'd get a psychiatric assessment," he added.

McNally said the military has attempted to address Keddy's psychiatric issues.

"(Counselling) programs have been set up for him, but he has not been attending," she said. "They can set these things up, but it's his responsibility to comply."

"If he's mentally ill, maybe he can't," McCarroll suggested.

"He went overseas, saw some terrible things, is suffering from some type of stress situation and he needs help."

"What irks me here is they're setting all the rules and we've got to somehow fit within those rules," he said. The judge also found it strange that no military representative was present for the court proceedings, despite being aware of the charges against Keddy.

"It must be terribly frustrating for you as parents," he said.

"You're really holding your tongues very well."

McCarroll released Keddy on an agreement with the court to keep the peace and be of good behaviour, to remain at the base unless accompanied by a parent, to undergo a psychiatric assessment at the mental health clinic in Saint John, to follow through with any counselling and to take prescribed medications.

"Hang in," McCarroll told Keddy.

Sentencing on the assault charge is scheduled for Burton court on Nov. 24, while sentencing for breaching the no-contact order is slated for Dec. 8, once a pre-sentence report is prepared.

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (9)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Most of the services being provided for this type of distress has been (so I'm told) contracted to a "Lowest Bidder" you get what you pay for...smoke and mirrors.
Quality care is what is required for our brave troops ASAP
23
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
A. Harper, lincoln on 10/11/08 07:34:33 AM AST
my treatment consists of closing my eyes and listening to the ocean while flexing my muscles.
2
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
D. F, OROMOCTO on 10/11/08 12:32:49 PM AST
This is a little stupid, the guy was given treatment and refused or missed it. He has been a real ass and shown a complete lack of interest in his own well being. How many times should the military be responsible for his lack of cooperation? 3 7 9 or 1000? Come being a patient assumes that the patient wants to get well, this guy does not!
4
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
D. F, OROMOCTO on 10/11/08 06:34:42 PM AST
Most of the treatment has been contracted to the civil servants and very highly paid!
0
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
D. F, OROMOCTO on 10/11/08 06:35:55 PM AST
This really disturbs me. I understand where some of these men have had trouble and I in no way am attempting to demean what they do but there is another side to these sad stories. The Victims side. In this particular case, if what I've read is true, there seems to be a decision already available from Judge McCarroll and this is in the article when he says to the detainee, "Hang In". Which sounds to me like he's already got the judges sympathy and likely won't be held responsible for his actions. At what point do people who break the law be expected to take responsibility for their own "Chosen" actions. There was also a family destroyed in this as well, not just the "soldier" and what about the spouse who had to endure not one but two seperate occassions of assault. Has the military offered her any help? The help is available to help deal with PTSD, (if indeed this is why the assaults happened)but unless the person involved understands he has issues it's pointless.
4
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
L. Young, Saint John on 11/11/08 12:21:31 AM AST
How many times was his girlfriend harrassed, threatened and assaulted until finally she called the police. I thank the military for giving me the freedom I so enjoy and yes take for granted sometimes but there are laws and if we continue to allow people to blame their actions on anything and everything,and accept no responsibility, than we as a society are saying "We understand you have some problems and have had a hard life so far so we won't hold you accountable for what you do". This will only increase the spouse abuse, assaults and harrasments. Maybe by the person dating your daughter next time. I can only imagine what time in Afganistan does to a person,that doesn't mean this type of behavior is acceptable or excusable. If these brave men and women are coming home in this kind of condition, perhaps some aren't suited for the type of career the military provides. There's a difference between a reason, and an excuse, one involves acceptance and one involves blame.
5
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
Larry Young, Saint John on 11/11/08 12:50:53 AM AST
"It must be Terribly frustrating for you as parents" says Judge McCarroll. Yes it must be. But again, where is his concern for the victim who was assulted, feels she can't put this behind her and move on because the "Victim" in the courts eyes is the assailant not her. I would like to know where this article came from and who requested it be published and to what end. We all know of the problems in the Canadian Military but these men and women are supposed to be protectors of the innocent and uphold what is right and decent. There is something so wrong with what is happening here. Yes get him help, but in the end, what do you do if he won't use it? You can give a man all the tools he needs to build a house, but unless that man "wants" to build the house, the tools just sit there rusting and the man is still complaining it's cold outside. There was deliberate actions taken to hurt someone on a number of occassions, there has to be accountability.
7
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
Larry Young, Saint John on 11/11/08 01:02:37 AM AST
K2000 Troop Support encourages all Canadians to step up to the plate and support our troops, they need help medically, morally. We have to take this responsibility. From the research that I have undertaken over many years on a personal basis, I have met, talked to many soldiers, families and friends and have seen the end result and this is a prime example.

WE HAVE TO DO MORE, THEY NEED OUR SUPPORT. I personally crossed Canada this year on the K2000 TROOP SUPPORT TOUR, and plan on doing again next year to bring awareness to this problem. There are many, too many to list here.

If there are Canadians who wish to help, it would be helpful. We have to take this seriously. There will be many more stories like this. Lets all support our troops and their families.

K2000 TROOP SUPPORT, JOSEPH BONNEVIE, MONCTON NB joeb@nb.sympatico.ca 506=384-6232

GOD BLESS OUR TROOPS AND THEIR FAMILIES.
4
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
JOSEPH BONNEVIE, Moncton on 16/11/08 02:29:33 PM AST
ONCE A WIFE OR GF IS KILLED WILL THE MILITARY STAND UP AND HAVE TO DO SOME EXPLAINING. I KNOW VERY WELL THE LIFE HIS EX GIRLFRIEND IS LIVING IT BUT I AM A WIFE AND WE HAVE CHILDREN TOGETHER. MAKES IT A BIT HARDER TO CUT OFF ALL CONTACT. TRUST ME THE MILITARY DON'T GIVE A SH!T ABOUT THE SOLDIERS. TALK ABOUT MENTAL HEALTH ON THE BASE OR MRI BEING UNABLE TO HANDLE IT IS TOTALLY TOTALLY TRUE.
PRETTY SAD IF YOU ASK ME ALL I CAN HOPE FOR IS THAT I AM NOT DEAD BEFORE MY HUSBAND GETS THE HELP HE NEEDS.........AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC DOESN'T KNOW ANYTHING NOR DO THEY CARE EITHER UNTIL SOMEONE IS HURT.
1
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
eagle spirit, patriotic heart on 19/11/08 02:49:29 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles