$10B power play

Published Thursday October 29th, 2009

Energy Graham, Charest reach historic accord that would see NB Power sold to Hydro-Québec

A1

FREDERICTON - The New Brunswick and Quebec governments have reached a deal worth close to $10 billion that would see Hydro-Québec buy most of NB Power, The Telegraph-Journal has learned.

Click to Enlarge
Andrew Vaughan/Telegraph-Journal Archive Photo
In June 2007, Premier Shawn Graham enthusiastically greeted Jean Charest as the Quebec premier arrived for a meeting of New England governors and Eastern Canadian premiers in Prince Edward Island. The two politicians are expected to announce today that Hydro-Québec is buying most of NB Power.

The agreement, which will be announced today by Premier Shawn Graham and Quebec Premier Jean Charest, would see Hydro-Québec swallow NB Power's $4.8-billion debt and offer another $5 billion in savings for New Brunswick ratepayers, according to documents summarizing the agreement.

In exchange, Quebec's public utility will own most of NB Power's operations and secure for itself a vital pipeline into energy-hungry New England.

If the accord clears legislative and political hurtles, it will see power rates frozen for five years for residential and commercial ratepayers in New Brunswick. After that, all rate increases will be tied to inflation and the cost of building new power plants.

Industrial power rates in New Brunswick, meanwhile, will be lowered to match those in Quebec, which are among the lowest in North America.

Graham and Charest are scheduled to sign a memorandum of understanding today at Government House, the stately residence of New Brunswick's lieutenant-governor in Fredericton. NB Power chief executive officer David Hay and Thierry Vandal, president and CEO of Hydro-Québec, are also slated to take part.

The deal between the two provinces, which won't be made official until next year, follows months of negotiations between the two sides.

When the talks began in June, Graham said the sessions would focus on securing more cheap hydroelectric power from Quebec, perhaps in exchange for the use of New Brunswick's electrical grid.

Instead, the end deal would see Quebec take ownership of the entire electrical grid, including NB Power's international power lines running into the United States.

That increased access to the New England market is the biggest advantage for Quebec. That's because New Brunswick's grid would allow Hydro-Québec to pump more of its hydroelectric power to the American market.

For the Graham government, the benefits are obvious. By removing NB Power's debt, the Grits will slay 40 per cent of the province's total debt in one fell swoop.

And it would end an era of rising power rates in New Brunswick - at least in the short term.

By freezing power rates for five years, the deal would exceed a commitment made by the Liberal government to limit annual rate increases to three per cent until 2011.

As well, captains of industry would likely welcome the deal.

Last year, for example, the heads of three large forestry companies said the Graham government should quickly reduce industrial power rates to prevent further mill closures, job losses and general crisis in the already-ailing forestry sector.

The presidents of Fraser Papers, Flakeboard and J.D. Irving, Limited, bemoaned uncompetitive electricity costs, which they blamed for numerous mill closures and thousands of layoffs in New Brunswick.

The proposed deal is also likely to face protests in some corners, especially considering Graham promised to maintain NB Power as a publicly-owned utility during the 2006 election.

In recent days, Graham has declined to provide details about the talks between his government and Quebec.

"Ultimately, we want to provide lower electricity rates for New Brunswickers than can be provided under the current structure of NB Power," he said. "We also know there's a debt of over $4 billion "¦ and our government is looking at ways of dealing with this challenging and crippling debt load."

 

Comments (54)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

This is not good news for the "working people" at NB Power.
135
Thumbs Up
35
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Little Guy, NB on 29/10/09 06:12:01 AM AST
Big rate cuts for big business, and a few crumbs thrown to the little guy. Typical NB politics.

At least the little guy gets a chance to show Shawn Graham what's up in the next election.
144
Thumbs Up
36
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
John McLane, Nashwaaksis on 29/10/09 06:46:16 AM AST
Jimmy Durante would be envious of this guys trademark; the ability to 'hoover' Quebec selling NB to Quebec and help cut NF hopes to transmit power tot market must make this guy proud!!

Sept 27, 2010 -- by Shawnocchio!!!
89
Thumbs Up
21
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
T. Wright, Greater Moncton on 29/10/09 06:55:09 AM AST
"Hurtles" definition:

VERB:
To move with or as if with great speed and a rushing noise: an express train that hurtled past.
To fling with great force; hurl.

Quentin Casey, the author, sure shows bad grammar in Para4 using this word. Did you mean 'hurdles' Quentin? Use a dictionary if you want to be considered a good writer.

27
Thumbs Up
36
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Tom Wright, Greater Moncton on 29/10/09 07:09:18 AM AST
Graham has made it clear he only cares about big companies in this province, no concern at all for the working people of New Brunswick truth be known little Frank is calling the shots for the liberals in this province behind his desk at td bank. Graham and his party have droped the ball on NB power, health care, education and the ferry service how many more blunders can he and his party make.I live in Ed Doherty's riding and he has no clue, useless as a mla, next election I WOULD EVEN VOTE FOR RANDY BO BANDY FROM THE TRAILER PARK BOYS OVER HIM.
121
Thumbs Up
28
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
d roberts, saint john on 29/10/09 07:19:36 AM AST
I welcome the Sale of NB Power. This province need someone that knows how to run the utility. As a former Quebecer, I know Hydro-Quebec will do a great job for NB. Trust the move.
43
Thumbs Up
138
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
H Leblanc, SJ on 29/10/09 07:20:06 AM AST
This deal is great for the little guy. Rates frozen for 5 years and indexed after. 5 billion dollar savings for the little guy. The little guy also pays the 5 billion dollar debt and now that is payed off overnight. 10 Billion savings in total. Now own children will not be responsible for 5 billion in debt that we ran up, it will be payed off. Good for everyone this deal
42
Thumbs Up
112
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Ideas Everywhere, Fredericton on 29/10/09 07:23:26 AM AST
The rate cut for industry helps us all. It will create and/or save jobs, plus it will attract outside investment (remember, NB will also have lowest corporate tax rate in Canada soon).

Also, stabilizing residential rates is nothing to sneeze at. With the scheduled increases over the next few years, you can be that the average household will save hundreds if not thousands.
35
Thumbs Up
79
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Paul McCarthy, Saint John on 29/10/09 07:38:30 AM AST
Good for the little guy? Are you people complete and utter idiots? The rates will be frozen for a short period of time, and then raised to cover the cost of buying the utility. You think Quebecers will pay that? No NBers will. While the Irvings get the cheap power they have demanded for years. If you think those savings will be passed along you are senile or smoking awfully good weed. Do you expect the price of gas and toilet drop? Graham has screwed several generation of NBers with this deal.
104
Thumbs Up
29
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
If Only, Desolation Settlement on 29/10/09 07:52:47 AM AST
The Party of REAL SECRET AGENDAS AND FLIP FLOPS has done it again. So suck it up NRBers, you voted for them. For sure, for sure, Anglos need not apply as we all know Que's policy on bilingualism and we all know what the working language of Que Hydro
We're just one giant step closer to being a Little Quebec and the unbeliveable part is that the little guy never got one honest vote on any of it, be it Feds or provincial.... and we're supposed to live in a democracy.
But this is just my imagination because the media keeps telling us that its Harper who is scary and who has a secret agenda.
83
Thumbs Up
30
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
. MCLAUGHLIN, Quispamsis on 29/10/09 07:59:08 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles