Tories question ferry move

Published Tuesday April 28th, 2009
A3

FREDERICTON - The Opposition Conservatives are baffled as to why a former Liberal MLA is being paid to help reverse the Grits' decision to scrap two cable ferries - when the Liberals originally cut the ferries to save money.

Click to Enlarge
STEPHEN MACGILLIVRAY PHOTO
Eric Allaby

On Monday, it was publicly revealed that former Fundy Isles MLA Eric Allaby is being paid to consult the government on the current ferry fiasco.

Allaby will help set up a volunteer community group, which will take over ownership of the Gagetown and Belleisle ferries.

The group will then contract out the service to a private operator. Allaby will also help the community group choose the private operator.

The Tories say the arrangement is suspect.

"Here, they've gone and spent some money to hire a friend of the party, who comes from an island (Grand Manan) - so they assume he's an expert on ferries - to do what the minister should already be doing," said Conservative Bev Harrison in an interview.

"The minister is the expert. At least he's suppose to be. He's got a staff quite capable of working with these citizens and coming up with the privatized solution," the Hampton-Kings MLA said.

"But what has he gone and done? Spent money to hire someone when they're trying to save money on the ferries in the first place.

"It doesn't make sense."

Allaby's emergence came just a day after the Liberals announced the Gagetown and Belleisle ferries would remain in service, but with a private operator and a significantly reduced schedule.

The Hampstead ferry, however, has not been spared the chopping block.

As announced in the recent provincial budget, the three river ferries were to be pulled from their runs at the end of this month. The services are being discontinued to save the province $1.5 million.

Under the new arrangement, said Allaby, the department of transportation will no longer operate the ferries.

Still, he wouldn't rule out the government supporting the ferries through grants or by covering liability for the service.

As well, he couldn't say when the province will finally step away from the two ferries.

That will all depend on how quickly the volunteer community group can be formed - and a private operator found.

So far, three potential contractors have shown interest in running the ferries: Armstrong Management Solutions Inc. of Chipman; East Coast Ferries Ltd. of Deer Island; and Tim Tupper of Jemseg.

"We want to do it as quickly as possible because the longer we drag this out, the more uncertainty there is," Allaby said.

Until then, the government will operate the two ferries daily, from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m.

Harrison called the new plan a "partial measure".

"People aren't terribly excited by this," he said. "But they're happy the boats haven't come out of the water."

Randy Smith, the mayor of Gagetown, stood shoulder to shoulder Monday with Allaby and Eugene McGinley, the Liberal MLA for Grand Lake-Gagetown.

He admitted that many questions are left unanswered, but said his community will have no trouble forming a volunteer group to oversee the ferry service.

"It's one more step towards a conclusion and one step further to a solution," he said.

Smith also praised the Liberals' budget - the very document that slashed his village's ferry in the first place.

Smith told reporters the government had "received accolades across the country for its budget."

 

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (5)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Liberal pockets being lined with cash...and a Mayor who then says Graham has a great budget, which must make him Liberal.

This is a slap in the face to anyone outside of gagetown who faces cuts (Mactaquac come to mind) that supported his towns cause.
8
Thumbs Up
9
Thumbs Down
D. Breeze, Bathurst on 28/04/09 06:50:26 AM AST
I am so embarrassed to live in this community and I want the world to know a silent majority have been very upset by the hysteria of the last few weeks. We could not speak out for fears of reprisals. D. Breeze, you are so right, this is a slap to every NB community that is facing the cancellation of programs that REALLY matter. Gagetown has a safer, faster, four-lane link to Cambridge-Narrows and Jemseg in its backyard. Who in their right mind is going to wait and wait for the ferry and THEN pay a toll for the privilege? All this fuss is a complete waste of time and energy, not to mention the cash. A sad day for Gagetown, the government and most importantly, the people of New Brunswick. And we'll see how long the volunteers can cope with the ferry.
7
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
stop the insanity, Gagetown on 28/04/09 11:57:29 AM AST
First the Tories criticized the cancelation of the ferries and now they are criticizing the means to bring them back. Can't they make up their minds on anything? How can they criticize both sides of the question?
5
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
J. R, Moncton, NB on 28/04/09 12:45:40 PM AST
stop the insanity, Gagetown wrote: "And we'll see how long the volunteers can cope with the ferry."

And I'm sure we'll also see a handful of loudly gloating naysayers cheering, saying 'I told you so', and doing nothing but sneering on the web, if these volunteers -- who are giving their time and energy to keep services in their community -- fail in their efforts.
3
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
C P, Sackville on 28/04/09 02:02:25 PM AST
Alaby will help choose the operator... oh which big Liberal will get this position. What a joke. All of this to save $1.5 million... a small fraction of the $60 million this reckless government gave to the Caisse Populair, run by a former Liberal Premier. Maybe the Caisse could give DOT a loan to keep the ferries running.
2
Thumbs Up
1
Thumbs Down
Junior Ketty, Woodstock on 29/04/09 08:42:46 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles