Reversal of the 'biggest mistake in education'

Published Wednesday May 14th, 2008

Reform Three-year plan unveiled for skilled trades and technology education

A1

FREDERICTON - For students to thrive, they need to learn about subject matter that interests them, rather than being force-fed a "one-size-fits-all" curriculum, Kelly Lamrock says.

Click to Enlarge
Ed Doherty

That theory forms the basis of reforms the education minister introduced Tuesday, which include bolstering trade and technology course options in anglophone high schools across the province.

Lamrock, who admits he performed at the back of the pack in his own high school shop class, said children need options that make them excited about the process of learning.

"Imagine if someone had said to (me) in school, you should just focus all your time in the shop till you pass it, and don't take English or writing or all the things you love doing," Lamrock said during a meeting with the Telegraph-Journal's editorial board.

"In a proper school, you have to celebrate the strengths of every child, and you have to give them a chance to succeed at something, give them a reason to get up and be engaged learners."

A key target of Lamrock's three-year plan for restructuring skilled trades and technology education involves collaborating with the Department of Post-Secondary Education, Training and Labour.

Post-Secondary Minister Ed Doherty and Lamrock were both on hand at Simonds High School in Saint John to sign an agreement to develop dual enrolment opportunities, where students receive community college credit for work done in trades-related high school courses.

The plan also involves strengthening partnerships with industry to provide more hands-on training opportunities for students, in addition to a $2-million investment to retrofit and enhance shop facilities and provide professional development for teachers.

The partnerships aspect is a major red flag when it comes to serving rural schools fairly, according to Conservative MLA Mike Olscamp, who taught for 31 years.

"I have some very serious reservations about that," Olscamp said, noting access to industry resources is limited in rural areas, with many major businesses based in large cities, such as Saint John.

"It's another attack on rural New Brunswick."

Olscamp also raised concerns over where the province will find enough qualified teachers to staff the new trades courses, noting strong incentives will be needed to lure qualified individuals away from higher paying jobs.

Brent Shaw, president of the New Brunswick Teachers' Association, echoed those concerns, adding the province has reached a "breaking point" in terms of its pool of high-school trades teachers.

There are only 45 currently, he said, and about half are expected to retire in the next 20 years.

Though the new initiative is "not nearly enough," Shaw said, he's pleased to see a renewed emphasis on trades training, calling past cutbacks in vocational programs "the biggest mistake in education we've had."

For his part, Doherty lauded the initiative as a means of boosting the number of students transitioning from high school to community college programs.

He also pointed to future benefits tied to the Liberal government's self-sufficiency agenda.

"To achieve our shared goal of self-sufficiency (by 2026), New Brunswick needs its young people to be aware of their options and equipped with the skills to pursue their goals," Doherty said.

The skilled trades and technology initiative is linked to the Model Schools Project, also announced Tuesday, designed to probe successful teaching and leadership practices and offer more opportunities for students to learn through real-world applications and problem-solving.

Please Log In or Register FREE

You are currently not logged into this site. Please log in or register for a FREE ONE Account.
Logged in visitors may comment on articles, enter contests, manage home delivery holds and much more online. Your ONE Account grants you access to features and content across the entire CanadaEast Network of sites.

Comments (17)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

"For students to thrive, they need to learn about subject matter that interests them, rather than being force-fed a "one-size-fits-all" curriculum, Kelly Lamrock says"

Is he on our side now? Seems to me that the new FSL plan resembles a "one-size-fits-all" curriculum and as far as I've been able to determine it's about to be "force fed.

"Imagine if someone had said to (me) in school, you should just focus all your time in the shop till you pass it, and don't take English or writing" Lamrock said

Hmm, what happens to the above sentence when you take the words "in the shop" and replace them with "on English Literacy" and then the words "take English or writing" and replace them with "worry about being Bi-lingual."

It's too bad that a personal bias is preventing him from realizing that both of the above statements only highlight the problems with his new FSL plan.

94
Thumbs Up
19
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 6:36:14 AM ADT
Is the man capable of realizing when he contradicts himself? Honestly, he has no idea what he is doing. He's an idea man but doesn't think any of his wild ideas through to implementation.
In theory, bringing these classes back would be great. IN reality- it's causing STREAMING!!!!!!!! I thought streaming was the big, bad evil.
85
Thumbs Up
13
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 7:30:43 AM ADT
I think this is an excellent approach to meeting the needs of students, and the workforce.

But the irony is hard to swallow - "Universal" French for all, but for this, he says "one-size-fits-all" doesn't work.

His bias against French is painfully plain to see.
92
Thumbs Up
16
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 7:45:45 AM ADT
I think we'll be waiting to hear about the reversal of 'the biggest mistake in Education' again...

Taking away the chance for any of our children to actually become bilingual.

83
Thumbs Up
10
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 8:45:07 AM ADT
So now choice is good and one size fits all is bad?

Well just imagine Kelly, if some know-it-all Education Minister had canceled your English Literacy and writing and forced you to take nothing but shop because the English classes caused streaming and he wanted to use you to boost the shop classes standardized test scores...
83
Thumbs Up
9
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anne Onymous, Fredericton on 14/05/08, 8:53:29 AM ADT
"Olscamp also raised concerns over where the province will find enough qualified teachers to staff the new trades courses." "Brent Shaw, president of the New Brunswick Teachers' Association, echoed those concerns"

So, we get rid of a program because we don't have "resources" to make it more accessible--experts weigh in and say we're doing the wrong thing.

We add "Phys-Ed and Music"--experts say we don't really have the proper resources to support these programs.

We add "trade and technology course options" and two more experts weigh in by saying we don't really have the resources needed to teach the programs.

At least we're consistent--we don't listen to "any" experts.
76
Thumbs Up
6
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 8:59:57 AM ADT
When will politicians realize education - the teaching of our children regardless of the subject - has little to do with a 4 year election cycle (surely you must remember the mess Mckenna made and the Scraba Report of 2002) and everything to do with a 15 to 20 year cycle.

All this talk about EFI, and trades, and performance levels on national tests is important, but misses the root of the problem.

Get the politicians out of the implementation level decision-making of the education system. Give authority back to the professionals who teach and administer as a daily practice (and hope to goodness they can reach some level of consensus).

Most of all, make learning ... no matter what type of learning ... exciting again!
74
Thumbs Up
1
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Dennis Atchison, Fredericton on 14/05/08, 9:19:58 AM ADT
How does he do it? His ability to speak from both corners of his mouth almost at the same time is remarkable. Another pronouncement by Lamrock and "the biggest mistake in Education" is remediated. Reinstituting tech and vocational programmes is a laudable goal and a necessary initiative, but it will be a longterm process which will not much benefit rural schools. As well, there are precious few "shop" teachers left. My point is that this minister has a very poor understanding of his portfolio. He believes that he can magically rule by edict and decree. He's a "big picture guy" who has little understanding of details or the conservative nature of education which tends to evolve slowly rather than transform itself rapidly. Like Hitler, who in the last months of the war, continued to commit imaginary forces to battle, Lamrock is relying on imaginary French, art, music, phy.ed and vocational ed. teachers to rapidly implement his plans. It's time to recall the biggest mistake in Education.
71
Thumbs Up
5
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 9:22:26 AM ADT
For his part, Doherty lauded the initiative as a means of boosting the number of students transitioning from high school to community college programs.

Soooo does that mean your finally going to come through and put the 12,000 new seats in Community Collages?? ya didn't think so, thank god I got into a program this year in St. Andrew's before Kelly gets his "turn gold to crap" hands on it.
62
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 9:23:00 AM ADT
It is difficult to believe an educated person like Mr Lamrock can contradict himself to the extent he does and not realize it. Now he says one size fits all does not work yet he wants Intensive French for all in grade five. Choice is good for everything else but bad when it comes to learning a second language.

It is time to reverse the greatest mistake in Education: replace Mr Lamrock as minister of education.
61
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 14/05/08, 11:03:10 AM ADT
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles